Between the Sheets: An IBA Cocktail Challenge
A Classic Worth Trying
Between the Sheets is one of those classic cocktails I’ve heard about for years but never actually tried—until now. Part of the IBA list, this drink is often overshadowed by its close relative, the Sidecar, but it deserves its own spotlight.
The blend of cognac, white rum, triple sec, and lemon juice creates a balanced, sophisticated flavor that’s both refreshing and complex. It seemed like a drink I’d enjoy based on the recipe, and I wasn’t disappointed. Let’s dig into the ingredients, technique, and flavor profile.
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links.
Ingredients Breakdown
- Cognac – Provides a rich, warming base with notes of dried fruit and spice.
- White Rum – Adds a light, slightly sweet character, balancing the depth of the cognac.
- Triple Sec – Brings citrusy sweetness, enhancing the drink’s complexity.
- Fresh Lemon Juice – Adds brightness and acidity, tying everything together.
Technique and Glassware
To make Between the Sheets, you’ll need a cocktail shaker and a double strainer grab this set from Viski. This ensures the drink is well-chilled and free of ice shards. Serve it in a chilled coupe glass, which keeps the drink at the right temperature and adds a touch of elegance.
For the best results, shake vigorously to achieve a light, frothy texture. Double-strain into the coupe to capture fine ice particles, ensuring a smooth, polished presentation.
Tasting Notes
The first sip is bright and citrusy, followed by the warm complexity of cognac and the subtle sweetness of rum. The triple sec adds a delicate orange note, while the lemon keeps the drink crisp and refreshing. It’s a beautifully balanced cocktail that evolves as it warms slightly, revealing more of the cognac’s nuanced character.
History of Between the Sheets
The origin of Between the Sheets is shrouded in mystery, much like many classic cocktails. It’s often attributed to Harry’s New York Bar in Paris during the 1930s, a hotspot for American expats seeking familiar spirits during Prohibition. Some say it was a playful twist on the Sidecar, using rum to soften the sharpness of cognac. This strategic swap gave the drink a smoother, more approachable character while preserving its sophisticated allure.
What does Between the Sheets taste like?
Between the Sheets offers a refined balance of citrus, sweetness, and spirituous warmth. The interplay between cognac and white rum creates a layered depth, enhanced by the bright acidity of fresh lemon juice. The triple sec provides a touch of orange sweetness, rounding out the drink’s sharp edges. The result is a vibrant, crisp cocktail with a lingering complexity that keeps you coming back for more.
Is Between the Sheets a strong cocktail?
Yes, Between the Sheets is a potent drink due to its base of cognac and rum, both of which are high-proof spirits. Despite its strength, the drink maintains remarkable balance, with the citrus elements and triple sec tempering the booziness. It’s a sophisticated sipper, best enjoyed slowly to fully appreciate its evolving flavor profile.
Can I use dark rum instead of white rum?
While white rum is traditional for Between the Sheets, you can experiment with dark rum for a richer, more robust flavor. Dark rum adds deeper molasses notes and a more complex finish, creating a slightly heavier drink. However, this swap can alter the cocktail’s delicate balance, so proceed with caution if you choose to replace white rum.
What is the best cognac for Between the Sheets?
To make the best Between the Sheets, choose a VS or VSOP cognac for its vibrant fruit notes and balanced complexity. Cognacs like Hennessy VSOP or Rémy Martin VSOP are excellent options, as they provide the right depth without overpowering the other ingredients. Avoid overly aged or expensive cognacs, as their nuanced flavors may get lost in the mix.
Why is it called Between the Sheets?
The name Between the Sheets is as playful as the drink itself, believed to be a cheeky nod to the drink’s potency and its romantic associations. In the early 20th century, suggestive names were common in cocktail culture, adding a sense of intrigue and allure to the drinking experience. This provocative moniker has undoubtedly contributed to the cocktail’s mystique and enduring popularity.
Final Thoughts
Between the Sheets surprised me with its layered complexity. It’s a cocktail that feels both timeless and contemporary, with a flavor profile that invites you back for another sip. This IBA classic certainly earns its place on the list, and it’s one I’ll be making again.
Between the Sheets
A refined blend of rum, cognac, and citrus for a balanced, sophisticated sip.
Ingredients
- 30 ml Cognac
- 30 ml White Rum
- 10 ml Triple Sec
- 10 ml Fresh Lemon Juice
Instructions
- Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker filled with ice.
- Shake vigorously until well-chilled.
- Double strain into a chilled coupe glass.
- Garnish with a lemon twist.
